Fruit of the Doom? Is Fruit Sabotaging Your Weight Goals?

After a long day grinding it out in the world of sales, I used to have a ritual of buying an apple at a local Whole Foods for the 2-hour drive home.

Aww, what a healthy, hard-earned reward, right!?

Don’t let me fool you. I failed to mention the apple was literally the size of a coconut.

And as apple juice would pour down my cheeks from just one bite, I convinced myself that the double-ginormous apple had the same exact nutrition as a normal-sized apple.

Nevermind the 9 servings of fruit I previously ate that day, which was SO necessary and perfectly healthy. (Ha!)

About that government recommended “5-a-day??” I never understood how people couldn’t get theirs in, because I was CRUSHING it during breakfast alone! If there was a “Fruit Eater of the Year Award,” I was surely going to win the dang thing.

Yup, the typical day in the life of Julia included an average consumption of 4 – 12 servings of fruit a day.

Fruit of the Doom?

Well, that was all fine and dandy until it got to be quite an addiction over the years.

As in, I couldn’t go grocery shopping without consuming unwashed grapes in my grocery cart, to the point where I probably still have pounds of pesticide toxins in my system.

Energy swings, sugar cravings and constant hunger haunted me. Plus, that stubborn 5-10 pounds seemed to hang on like a stage-5 clinger from Wedding Crashers.

I was hungry all the time, and my blood sugar would crash HARD every hour or so. Fruit was my quick fix energy defibrillator.

Repeat. Repeat. Repeat.

What the heck! I thought fruit was HEALTHY, low in calories, and that more was better! 

The bottom line? Learn from me. I am a prime case study that fruit, when broken down by the body, is SUGAR. And too much of it on a consistent basis can sabotage even the most concerted efforts of wellness.

Toxic Fruit Sugar 

While fruit does contain beneficial vitamins, minerals, fiber, and phytonutrients, gone is the myth that fruit is a perfectly equal substitute for vegetables, which have a much higher nutrient-to-energy ratio than fruit.

Fruit is full of fruit sugar, or fructose, which is a poison in high doses.

In small doses, the liver can rapidly rid of it by converting it to liver glycogen, or energy storage, but this is only the case when there is space available to do so.

With the standard American diet heavy on carbohydrates and sugar, there most likely isn’t much storage, so the liver then converts the fructose directly into fat.

Why do you think bears load up on abundant fruit in summer prior to hibernation? Yup, they are well-versed in how to fatten themselves up to survive the long winter!

One study of women even showed that shifting 25% of dietary calories from glucose to fructose raises small dense LDL (“bad cholesterol”) by 45%, increases post-meal triglycerides to by 100%, and increases abdominal fat 4 times faster than glucose (Teff, KL, et al., 2004).

Let’s just say I’ve had terrible visions of me eating that coconut-sized apple, and my liver converting it directly into ab fat… YUCK.

What else?

Fructose, or fruit sugar, also promotes bacterial infections. 

Ever heard of candida overgrowth?! It’s a pretty common yeast infection due to overgrowth of harmful bacteria from exposure to modern-day environmental toxins, such as prolonged antibiotic use, and has a number of health implications including fatigue and weight gain (Wikipedia, 2012).

Consuming fructose can contribute to candida, or overgrowth of bad gut bacteria and other chronic bacterial infections, as bacteria LOVE to metabolize fructose (Jaminet, C. & Jaminet, SC, 2010).

And, as Dr. Catherine Shanahan states,

“With all that sugar, fruit just doesn’t make the grade as a health food. As I tell my patients, fruit is a more natural alternative to a candy bar. And fruit juice, which lacks fiber and many of the antioxidants, is little better than soda” (Shanahan, C. & Shanahan, L., 2009).

So, how does this information translate into what we should do regarding fruit consumption??

Best Times to Eat Fruit

1) In between meals or at the BEGINNING of a meal.

Though it seems odd, consuming fruit at the end of a meal can cause a lot of gas. Because it is so quickly digested compared to protein and fat, consuming fruit AFTER consuming the main meal means fruit isn’t able to digest as quickly. Thus, it sits in the  colon where bacteria feed on it, causing gas buildup and bloating.

2) In the morning. 

Our liver glycogen stores are probably nearly full on the American diet, and after an overnight fast, there may be only about 15g of fructose of room for our liver to covert to glycogen (the amount in TWO bananas)! Breakfast may be the best time to eat fruit because of this (Jaminet, P. & Jaminet, SC, 2010).

At night, our liver stores are most likely full, and we aren’t nearly as active, so eating fruit post-meal or before bed is just going to spike insulin and promote fat storage. 

3) Before or after a workout! 

Eating it prior to a workout will aid in using up the fruit sugar for energy rather than fat storage. Eating it after a workout, especially a high intensity interval workout where the metabolism is revved, allows it to be metabolized more quickly as well.

Best Low Carb Fruits to Eat

According to Mark Sisson in The Primal Blueprint, the fruits with relatively high glycemic values and low antioxidant values to eat in moderation include melons, mangoes, papayas, pineapples, nectarines and dates, bananas, oranges, tangerines, plums, grapes, pomegranates, and all dried fruits (Sisson, 2009).

The top fruits lowest in sugar and highest in antioxidants (organic, locally grown, of course!), include:

1. Berries!! (Raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, blackberries…)
2. Cherries
3. Prunes
4. Apples
5. Peaches
6. Pears
7. Figs
8. Grapefruit
9. Kiwis
10. Apricots (Sisson, 2010).

In sum, I’m not telling you to cut out fruit PERIOD, but just remember that vegetables are much greater bang for the buck with nutrient density!

Enjoy in moderation and remember what happened when Eve ate the apple… Kidding :)

References

Candida (fungus) – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. (n.d.). Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Retrieved October 1, 2012, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candida_(fungus).

Jaminet, P., & Jaminet, S. (2010). Perfect health diet: four steps to renewed health, youthful vitality, and long life. Cambridge, Ma.: YinYang Press.

Shanahan, C., & Shanahan, L. (2009). Deep nutrition: why your genes need traditional food. Lawai, HI: Big Box Books.

Sisson, M. (2009). The primal blueprint. Malibu, Calif.: Primal Nutrition.

Teff, KL, et al. Dietary fructose reduces circulating insulin and leptin, attenuates postprandial suppression of ghrelin, and increases triglycerides in women. J Clin Endocrinol Metabolism. 2004 June; 89(6):2963-72. http://pmid.us/15181085. 

Note: Jules’ Fuel uses affiliate links in some blog posts. If you make a purchase using one of these links, which costs the same either way, it’s a very, very small way to help me cover the cost of running this website. So, thanks!

7 responses on “Fruit of the Doom? Is Fruit Sabotaging Your Weight Goals?

  1. Wow . . . I’m glad I’m only a week into my diet!! I sure would have blown that weigh in . . . Ugggg – just when I thought I was doing pretty good eating mostly fruits and veggies! Thanks for the tip and I hope to see some really good “HEALTHY” alternatives to my sugar cravings. I agree our friuts are tainted with so many chemicals, I am sure I have pounds of them to eliminate from my system – any suggestions?

    • Eating really clean for 7-10 days with fresh and/or slightly cooked fruits and veggies, minimal meats, lots of water, vegetable juices and herbal teas can help flush out the system!

  2. Hi Patti! First, give yourself a pat on the back for making healthier lifestyle changes!!

    Eating a real, whole foods diet of mostly organic meats, veggies, nuts, healthy fats/oils, some fruits, and minimal healthy starches/100% whole grains is the best way to combat cravings. The less processed and sugary foods and drinks in your diet, the less your insulin will be spiked, which sends your blood sugar crashing and you to the kitchen to combat a craving!

    Also, most people don’t consume enough healthy fats (avocado, coconut oil, nuts, egg yolks) in their diet, which is our body’s preferred fuel source and very satiating to the appetite! Thus, adding in better and more fat sources can also help with your cravings.

    It can take 2-3 weeks sometimes to reset your body’s metabolism and tastebuds, but once you push through, you will feel so much better.

    There are many different types of detox plans, but eating this way is one type of detox! Be sure to throw in tons of vegetable varieties in your diet – especially greens! – they are like medicine, and aid in cleansing the body and fighting free radicals.

    Finally, try drinking non-caffeinated herbal teas in the morning with half of a fresh squeezed lemon. It is very alkalizing, cleansing, and helps your liver to detox!

  3. Wow! This is such great information. I wondered why I had put on a few pounds but had cut back on unhealthy food and was consuming more fruit. Now I have my answer. Thanks! :)

  4. I hope I don’t come off like I’m nit-picking, but by ‘fruit’ I assume you mean the *traditionally understood* tree fruits, not botanically defined fruit (i.e. the part of the plant that contains the seeds)?

    Things like apples, pears, bananas, etc; not squash, peppers, cucumbers?

  5. Great, its 9pm and I managed to get a dozen organic dried apricots in my mouth before I got to the part about not eating fruit before bed! lol Great post!

    • LOL don’t beat yourself up. :) Fruit isn’t a BAD thing, per se, it’s just how much your biochemistry needs it, and what you eat with it (to help mitigate effects of high blood sugar, etc.). It’s still much better than a slice of cake!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *